1

I am from Bangladesh. I am looking to apply for a PhD in Germany. 3 years back I was studying in Canada for a Bachelors degree, I was one semester short of graduating. Unfortunately due to COVID hitting my family business hard, I was unable to afford tuition and living expenses. I subsequently became homeless for about 4 months. While I was homeless I had my laptop and some expensive looking clothes and belongings. I was attacked by other homeless people quite badly twice (It was caught on CCTV once and the police came and took my statement and said they would like me to stand witness). This entire episode of me being homeless was a great shock to me. I was 1 semester away from graduating from a global top 100 school and I come from an upper middleclass family - I had never experienced something so extreme. When you add the assaults that I experienced - it left me in a very fragile mental state. Eventually after the second assault on me, I completely lost my senses. I started to get extremely paranoid.

A family friend invited me to come to Toronto to live with them. But my paranoia and weakened mental state had gotten the better of me, I left his house to live on the streets. I don't have much memory of that time other than being extremely scared and paranoid. The Toronto police found me by a public park yelling unintelligible things at them or sometimes at thin air. I believe I threw an empty plastic coffee cup at them because I was scared. They took me to the hospital. They found my passport on my person and because they had no emergency contact on their file for me so they called my embassy. They talked with a consulate diplomat who knows me (from previous passport renewals and meeting him once) and the diplomat from my consulate called my family back home, arranged to pay for my plane ticket and brought me back home before my visa expired. As far as I know the police did not call CBSA (Canadian Border Security Agency), and I was not deported (I called CBSA later on and they confirmed that there is no removal orders or deportation orders against me).

The diplomat had talked to my uncle, he said that there was no criminal case to my name. And "they did not take any action against him, there is only a record of him being homeless in Toronto." (paraphrasing). Back home I was taken to see a doctor and put on meds. I recovered pretty fast, the doctor did not officially diagnose me with a chronic mental illness, only said that I should keep taking the medication just to be safe since I had one episode of psychosis.

I am on my way to completing my Bachelors degree in Bangladesh with really good grades. I have always been a top student even in my O levels and A levels. I have no criminal record neither in Canada or Bangladesh. I plan on doing my Masters and PhD in Germany as I am in Computer Science and I find the Blue Card prospects quite attractive.

My question is: will my ordeal in Canada negatively affect my chances of getting a visa to Germany ? I would like to state again that I have no criminal record and I was never deported or overstayed my visa, I left willingly before my visa expired. My main concern is the content of my ramblings when I had lost my mind. I was extremely paranoid, I wasn't violent but I was yelling unintelligible things and I have some vague memories of yelling paranoid anti-government things. The police obviously did not take me seriously and took me to the hospital. I remember clearly the hospital declared me as not being a threat to myself or the public and they were gonna release me after giving me medication. Will this ordeal negatively affect my German visa application and should I mention this ordeal in my application ?

4
  • 1
    Is there any question in the application to which it would be relevant? Sounds like you've committed no crimes, haven't been arrested or deported, so in what context are you concerned?
    – littleadv
    Commented Sep 26 at 8:12
  • Unless there’s a specific question(s) about the experiences you describe, why would you mention anything other than what the application asks about?
    – Traveller
    Commented Sep 26 at 11:27
  • Damn, that's a crazy story. Glad to hear that you've been able to turn your life back around after that experience.
    – nikhil
    Commented Sep 26 at 18:14
  • Well, I am confused on whther I should disclose my ordeal in visa application since you are not supposed to withold any information during visa applications? I don't know if my ordeal is even worth mentioning. For e.g. what if in the interview the interviewer asks about my time in Canada and why I left ? And thanks Nikhil, it was hard work. Commented Sep 27 at 5:30

1 Answer 1

2

will my ordeal in Canada negatively affect my chances of getting a visa to Germany ?

I don't see how. Nothing of what you described is relevant to getting a student visa or blue card.

You seem to have cleared all your visa obligations, that is the important part to getting a new visa anywhere else.

Even if throwing an empty cup at a police officer were a crime and had been on file, that is not something that Germany cares about in visa applications.

Germany does not care about minor infractions. The German authorities start caring at a prison sentence of 2 years or more. Probably because that is the German limit where you cannot get a suspended sentence any more, this is the "this is very serious" line in Germany.

5
  • Thanks for your answer. That puts my mind at ease. Thing is I just didn't want to lie or withold information on a visa application. What if in the interview the visa officer asks about my time in Canada and why I left ? Commented Sep 27 at 5:29
  • Tell them your parents had financial problems at home during COVID and you didn't have the funds to continue your studies, so you left... that's the truth.
    – nvoigt
    Commented Sep 27 at 8:26
  • I see, will do. What about possibilities of a refusal due to "threat to public order" or some reason like that? I am concerned about this because I was homeless and taken to the hospital by police in a pretty messed up mental state(I mean I did throw an empty plastic cup at police). I am concerned that record of my ordeal will reach the German aithorities and I might get rejected as a threat to public order. Commented Sep 29 at 12:42
  • Being homeless or admitted to a hospital is not "a threat to public order". Insulting an officer is not. A threat to public order is joining ISIS, sending Anthrax to people, bombing school busses, or trying to overthrow the government. Seriously, Germany does not care for petty things like talking back to an officer, or throwing a cup. You are fine.
    – nvoigt
    Commented Sep 29 at 13:04
  • You have no idea how much that puts my mind at ease. Thing is I have always been a top student and somewhat of a model law abiding citizen. I completely let myself and my family down during my mental breakdown. I just cannot believe I behaved that way coming from the background I come from and I kick myself figuratively every night thinking about what an idiot I was. My shrink tells me that getting assaulted triggered that behaviour and its not my fault. But like every law abiding citizen, I am intensely worried that even the slightest misstep with the law will come back to haunt me. Commented Sep 30 at 7:18

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.